Mineral sunscreens fail Which? assessments


Worrying new Which? analysis reveals that many dear mineral sunscreens aren’t as much as the job of defending your pores and skin from the solar’s rays. 

All of the mineral-based merchandise we examined failed SPF or UVA assessments – and shockingly a number of merchandise failed on each counts. 

4 SPF 30 mineral-based sunscreens from Alba Botanica, Clinique, Hawaiian Tropic and Tropic Skincare – costing between £11.99 and £28 – didn’t come near offering the safety they declare to. They failed key solar safety assessments twice, utilizing two completely different samples, so we’ve named all of them Don’t Buys to keep away from.

A fifth product – Inexperienced Individuals Scent Free Solar Cream SPF 30, which makes use of mineral and chemical UV filters, failed to guard adequately from UVA, and can also be a Do not Purchase. 

Ideas for residing effectively – get our free Meals & Well being publication: store savvy, eat effectively, keep wholesome

The Do not Purchase mineral sunscreens that failed our assessments

Mineral sunscreens have develop into more and more well-liked lately, on account of considerations that chemical UV filters might have an environmental influence, and the truth that mineral blockers will be higher for these with delicate pores and skin. 

However concerningly, not one of the merchandise we examined did a very good job of defending you from the solar or offering the extent of safety claimed. Here is a rundown of the merchandise that failed and why:

Alba Botanica Delicate Mineral Sunscreen SPF 30 £11.99/113ml 

In our assessments, this sunscreen failed to offer even two thirds of its SPF 30 declare, and failed to guard adequately from UVA too. You gained’t discover any chemical UV filters – it depends solely on the minerals titanium dioxide and zinc oxide, and it is free from synthetic colors or artificial fragrances.

That may sound promising for delicate pores and skin victims, however primarily based on its disappointing solar safety take a look at outcomes, it’s a Don’t Purchase.

Clinique Mineral Sunscreen Lotions for Physique SPF 30 £26/125ml

Once we examined this dear mineral sunscreen it barely supplied a 3rd of its claimed SPF, and it failed to offer sufficient UVA safety both. 

It was simple to use, however that is not a lot use when it didn’t present sufficient solar safety in our assessments. And at £26 for 125ml, it’s additionally the most costly sunscreen we’ve examined. Don’t waste your cash.

Inexperienced Individuals Scent Free Solar Cream SPF 30 £25.50/200ml

We’re pleased with the extent of SPF safety supplied by this solar cream, which might be because of the inclusion of Isoamyl p-Methoxycinnamate (an authorized chemical UV filter, which Inexperienced Individuals state is from a pure supply). 

However sadly, it fell brief on UVA safety, failing our assessments. Sunscreens must move each assessments to be acceptable, and that is why this one is a Don’t Purchase.

Hawaiian Tropic Mineral Protecting Solar Milk SPF 30 £10.50/100ml

With 100% mineral-based UV safety, ‘reef-friendly’ claims and PETA certification, this mineral sunscreen from Hawaiian Tropic appears to have loads going for it, however the outcomes of our assessments left us involved.

We discovered that it solely supplied round two thirds of its SPF 30 declare in our assessments, that means it will not shield you as a lot as you count on. It is one other fail, and we don’t suppose you should purchase it. 

Tropic Pores and skin Shade Solar Cream SPF 30 £28/200ml

Described as ‘reef pleasant’ and mineral-based, this costly sunscreen would possibly really feel like a very good and inexperienced selection. Our utility testing panel thought it was simple to use whereas not feeling cheesy in your pores and skin. 

However, just like the others above, it didn’t ship on its SPF 30 declare in our assessments, registering little greater than a 3rd of the anticipated SPF. It additionally failed to offer enough UVA safety. Disappointing, and one other Don’t Purchase. 

Mineral vs chemical sunscreens: what is the distinction?

Chemical-based sunscreens use natural compounds, corresponding to octocrylene, to filter UV rays. They’re absorbed into the pores and skin and supply solar safety by absorbing UV rays, both releasing the vitality from the sunshine as warmth or altering the 3D form of the chemical, which then breaks down. 

Mineral sunscreens use inorganic minerals, normally titanium dioxide or zinc oxide, to offer safety from UV rays. These sit on high of the pores and skin when the sunscreen is utilized, moderately than being absorbed, and create a bodily barrier that acts like a mirror, reflecting and scattering UV mild. 

Some UV filtering chemical compounds that you simply’ll discover in most fashionable sunscreens have been linked to coral injury, which is why some folks need to keep away from utilizing them. They may also be higher for delicate pores and skin, which will be irritated by some chemical filters – and there are some considerations that chemical UV filters are absorbed into the bloodstream, although extra analysis is required.

What’s ‘reef-safe’ sunscreen?

Nikon Coolpix W300 underwater

Mineral sunscreens typically promote their environmental credentials, the most typical being that they’re ‘reef-safe’ or ocean-friendly. This tends to imply that two generally used chemical UV filters linked to coral bleaching – oxybenzone and octinoxate – aren’t used. In some locations, together with Hawaii, the sale of sunscreens containing these compounds is banned.

Nonetheless, phrases corresponding to ‘reef-safe’ and ocean-friendly aren’t regulated, so there is not any consensus on what they imply or which merchandise they are often utilized to.

Whereas environmental issues are essential, as is what works finest to your pores and skin, our assessments present a worrying sample of the mineral sunscreens examined failing to offer their claimed degree of SPF or UVA safety. Different unbiased European and American client teams that Which? works with internationally have had related findings in unbiased assessments. 

Sunscreens that handed our SPF and UVA assessments

We additionally examined eight sunscreens which use chemical UV filters as a part of our 2022 testing. These all handed each SPF and UVA assessments, and a few value lower than £3 a bottle. Merchandise which handed embody:

  • Asda Defend Moisturising Solar Lotion SPF30, £2.80/200ml – accessible from Asda
  • Avon Solar Physique Cream SPF30, £5/150ml  – accessible from Avon
  • Calypso Press & Defend Solar Lotion SPF30, £3.49/200ml  – accessible from Calypso Solar
  • Lloyds Pharmacy Solero Moisturising Solar Lotion SPF30, £7/200ml  – accessible from Lloyds Pharmacy
  • Morrisons Solar Defend & Nourish Solar Spray SPF30, £3.50/200ml – accessible from Morrisons
  • Piz Buin Allergy Solar Delicate Pores and skin Lotion SPF30, £8/200ml – accessible from Amazon, Asda, Ocado, Piz Buin, Sainsburys, and Superdrug 
  • Superdrug Solait Moisturising Solar Spray SPF30 Excessive, £5.49/200ml – accessible from Superdrug
  • Ultrasun Household SPF30, £26/150ml – accessible from  Boots, John Lewis, Marks & Spencer, Superdrug and Ultrasun

You’ll be able to see full take a look at outcomes, together with the Greatest Purchase sunscreens which had been rated extremely for ease of utility (logged in Which? members solely), in our solar cream evaluations.

Suncream shopping for information – SPF, UVA and UVB defined, how to decide on, and the advertising and marketing jargon to be careful for

Do not Purchase sunscreens: what the producers say

Clinique advised us it has performed exterior normal testing which helps its SPF claims and meets EU pointers for UVA: ‘All our merchandise are subjected to rigorous testing – we assure our claims are clinically legitimate. Our analysis and inspection course of means we’ve got full confidence within the integrity and efficacy of all elements and formulation.’

Edewell (producer of Hawaiian Tropic Mineral Protecting Solar Lotion) advised us it firmly disagrees with the testing outcomes obtained by Which?: ‘Our product’s solar safety issue has been examined by a good and internationally recognised lab to ISO 24444 and obtained an SPF results of 34.5. Its UVA safety surpasses minimal European and UK thresholds and we’ve obtained no complaints or reviews about adversarial reactions.’

Inexperienced Individuals stated it is puzzled why the imply measured UVA PF fell under the extent really helpful by the EU, and that it was within the technique of investigating this additional.

After retesting its product Tropic advised us: ‘The security of our prospects is and has all the time been our primary precedence. On receiving Which?’s outcomes, we disagreed totally with their findings. Our Pores and skin Shade SPF30 had been examined a number of occasions, with the final take a look at performed in August 2021, reaching an SPF ranking of 32.5. 

Within the curiosity of full peace of thoughts for our prospects, we’ve got now examined the identical batch of Pores and skin Shade SPF30 Which? examined with two exterior unbiased ISO accredited labs, receiving outcomes of SPF 32.3 and SPF 31. Our Pores and skin Shade SPF30 has now been validated by three exterior unbiased labs, exhibiting our dedication to making sure the integrity of our formulation. 

Our sunscreens are manufactured following the strictest GMP and ISO accredited requirements. We’re completely happy to share these reviews with anybody who requests them. As we have not been capable of validate Which?’s findings, we firmly consider they’re incorrect.’

Alba Botanica did not reply to our request for remark.

Which? sunscreen assessments

Our unbiased lab assessments reveal how effectively excessive avenue sunscreens shield pores and skin from UVA and UVB rays, the kinds of ultraviolet mild linked to pores and skin most cancers. UVA causes untimely pores and skin ageing and UVB causes sunburn. 

  • SPF claims – we shine a UVB lamp on to sunscreen utilized to volunteers’ backs. We document the purpose when pores and skin reddens and examine the smallest quantity of UVB required with and with out the sunscreen. The distinction between the 2 factors is used to calculate the SPF. 
  • UVA safety – we unfold the sunscreen on a glass plate, place it within the path of a spectrophotometer and document the UVA radiation absorbed by the sunscreen. 

Each assessments are carried out to agreed British and Worldwide take a look at requirements. Any fails are topic to a repeat take a look at with a contemporary pattern from a distinct bottle.

Along with these core assessments, we get a various panel of a minimum of 10 folks to price every sunscreen on how simple it’s to use, ranking components corresponding to odour, absorption, residue, tackiness and greasiness. 

Merchandise are anonymised, and the merchandise rated finest for utility are named Greatest Purchase solar screens. See our high picks by logging in and checking our solar cream evaluations.

Need extra ideas for residing effectively? Signal as much as our free Meals & Well being publication right here

Discover the finest solar lotions that aced our unbiased lab assessments and discover out how we take a look at sunscreens 

Costs right as of 16 June 2022


Supply hyperlink